The problem typically solved by dependency injection in object-oriented programming is solved in a completely different way in functional programming.

Several years ago, I wrote a book called Dependency Injection in .NET, which was published in 2011. The book contains examples in C#, but since then I've increasingly become interested in functional programming to the extend that I now consider F# my primary language.

With that combination, it's no wonder that people often ask me how to do dependency injection in functional programming.

I've seen more than one answer, from other people, explaining how partial function application is equivalent to dependency injection. In a small series of articles, I'll explain both why this is true, but also why it's not functional. I'll conclude by showing a functional alternative to decoupling logic and (side) effects.

Bob: How do I do dependency injection in Scala? Other man: You don't, because Scala is a functional language. Bob: Fine, it's functional. How do I inject dependencies? Other man: You use a free monad which allows you to build a monad from any Functor. Bob: Did you just tell me to go fuck myself? Other man: I believe I did, Bob.

(Comic courtesy of John Muellerleile and Igal Tabachnik.)

There's another school of functional programmers who believe that dependency injection in functional programming involves a Free monad.

You can often make do with less, though.

In my experience, it's usually enough to refactor a unit to take only direct input and output, and then compose an impure/pure/impure 'sandwich'. You'll see an example later.

This article series contains the following parts:

  1. Dependency injection is passing an argument
  2. Partial application is dependency injection
  3. Dependency rejection
All articles revolve around a common example, which is one of my favourite scenarios: on-line restaurant reservation. You can see an actual example client in my Functional Architecture with F# Pluralsight course. The (somewhat dated) client source code is available on GitHub. The server-side F# and Haskell example code for this article series is available on GitHub.

The scenario is to implement an HTTP-based API that can accept incoming JSON documents that represent restaurant reservations.

I should point out that nowhere in this article series do I reject dependency injection as a set of object-oriented patterns. In object-oriented programming, dependency injection is a well-known and comprehensively described way to achieve decoupling and testability. In the next article, you'll see a brief review of dependency injection in C#.

Next: Dependency injection is passing an argument.

Wish to comment?

You can add a comment to this post by sending me a pull request. Alternatively, you can discuss this post on Twitter or Google Plus, or somewhere else with a permalink. Ping me with the link, and I may add it as a comment.


Friday, 27 January 2017 07:55:00 UTC


"Our team wholeheartedly endorses Mark. His expert service provides tremendous value."
Hire me!